Almost 9 years later, I am still in search of the perfect solution to this question. I actually wrote this headline almost 2 years ago. Today as I started to share my latest pursuit for a solution, I found a draft of this post with just the headline. I guess I had no answer until now. Skip on to the end if you can’t wait to know how I solved this problem.
For moms out there that are struggling to juggle a diaper bag and a purse, or have moved on from packing everything but the kitchen sink for your little one to a mommy purse or mommy tote – here are a few suggestions that has worked for me. At the time I write this, the kids are ages 3,3, 7, 8 1/2, 8 1/2.
- If you still need a diaper bag, consider a clutch or wristlet big enough to hold your essentials like credit cards, ID, cash, lipstick, hand sanitizer, and tissues but small enough to tuck into your diaper bag. Move the rest to a tote or bag you can access in emergency like in the trunk of your car, or a carryon suitcase if you’re traveling.
- If you’ve graduated to toddlers, consider carrying only the number of diapers and wipes you need for your outing, only one set of extra clothes, and a smaller portion of snacks. Use another tote or bag with the “extras” you think you’ll need. You can still keep it close by to replenish your diaper bag but at least you won’t be carrying around another 20 pounds of gear you “might” need. A cooler in the car can store additional juice or water. Use this in conjunction with a clutch or wristlet or an “insert” bag described below for your essentials.
- A larger purse or tote can replace your diaper bag when you’ve graduated from diapers and moved on to potty training. My diapers were replaced with a pack of toilet seat covers just in case we needed it while traveling. A clutch or wristlet with your essentials can easily be used by itself when you run into a store so you can leave the larger purse or tote in the car.
So what about all the other things you need to carry around with you but won’t fit in your clutch or wristlet? For me these are eyeglasses, a portable phone charger and cable, and feminine products at that time of the month. I keep this in a separate pouch – you can use a make up bag, pencil pouch, travel organizer or whatever you have on hand. I find the less structured ones are easier to squeeze in to my tote or purse. This pouch can be left in the car or kept in your purse or tote if you have room.
The final grievance I have as a mom is that I also need to carry my laptop back and forth to work or when I travel. I occasionally also bring my lunch or walking shoes to work. This is yet another bag to carry around when it’s time to go to work.
Another problem? Purses and totes are not that convenient when you need your hands free to hold your child.
I’m sure I’m not the only one that hates moving my wallet, phone, glasses, makeup etc from purse to diaper bag to work bag. There are a number of purse organizers that I have tried but none lasted.
At last – what has worked for me is the bag-in-bag approach. I really wish I thought of this before. Here’s how it works
- The first bag I will call the “insert” is a canvas backpack I found for $20 online. It’s plain, black, but durable and most importantly washable. In this bag I have my wallet, eyeglass case, electronics pouch and on occasion the pouch for feminine essentials. I do not carry my makeup with me – it stays home or goes in the car if I need to touch up.
- The 2nd bag I will call the “shell” is what the first bag or “insert” goes into. Depending on the occasion, this is a more stylish purse, a structured tote for work, a tote for shopping or running errands. I can throw my insert into the shell and still have my essentials with me, but change the style of my shell as I like. I usually will carry my water bottle in this bag too.
- On the weekends, I will usually carry my purse and place the insert bag inside. If I need to look more ‘acceptable’ , I carry the purse, but if I’m just taking the kids to the park, I ditch the purse in the trunk and use the insert which is a backpack. From time to time, I bring a larger tote as the “shell” vs a purse when I know I’ll need a shopping bag or library book bag instead.
- On workdays, my purse doubles as a work tote for my laptop. I have a laptop sleeve to protect it, then in goes my backpack “insert” with everything else. This makes it easy for me to leave the laptop at home on the weekends and just toss it back in on Monday. An “insert” makes it easier to switch from weekend purse to workday tote if you keep them separate.
I wish I could say I am a genius for thinking of this bag-in-bag approach but there is actually a start-up company that has designed a (rather large and expensive) tote with interchangeable shells and standard insert. I’m happy enough to have someone validate my idea 🙂
Here are some tips if you want to try this approach
- Choose a bag you use for your insert that is flexible vs structured, and has enough style that you’ll be happy to carry on its own. Mine is canvas and a backpack.
- Choose purses that can pull dual duty as a work tote, laptop bag, or diaper bag. I tend to choose larger purses, so yes you can be stylish and not carry a diaper bag.
- Minimize what is in your insert. If you’re not sure you can survive an outing without everything you have packed in your diaper bag or tote or gym bag now, separate them into pouches or whatever bags you already have, then try leaving them in the trunk. Eventually you’ll know what you always have to go back for vs what you can leave behind and retrieve only in emergencies.
- As you switch to this new “system” resist the temptation to buy the “perfect” organizer. I found an unused luxury brand name coin purse I was not using that I now use as my electronics pouch, a fashionable pencil case for my other essentials, and an unused luxury brand name wristlet that I was able to use as my wallet. These all go in my insert bag. The reason I chose them is they don’t add much bulk or weight but helps organize what goes into the insert.
Moms – go forth and rejoice! The purse vs diaper bag dillemma is solved!